How the 'Builder's Remedy' Is Disrupting Planning and Development in California

The state of California has long looked the other way while cities blocked growth. With the state now enforcing growth plans, more and more cities are faced with losing local control of zoning. Introducing the “Builder's Remedy."

2 minute read

October 25, 2022, 9:00 AM PDT

By James Brasuell @CasualBrasuell

Santa Monica Bay

The extent of California's 'Builder's Remedy' will be tested in Santa Monica, among other cities that failed to meet the state's standards for the Regional Housing Needs Assessment process in 2022. | Gert Hochmuth / Shutterstock

One of the biggest stories in planning anywhere in the country right now is the growing number of California cities that have run afoul of state requirements for the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) process, forfeiting local control of zoning approvals in the process and ushering a new planning term that completely upends the planning status quo: the Builder's Remedy.

An article by Liam Dillon for Los Angeles Times sheds new light on the Builder's Remedy, a policy tool that could have pressed local governments to plan for more housing, but went unused until reports about the city of Davis' being among the first in the state to face the consequences of failing the RHNA process. Davis would soon be followed by cities like Santa Monica. Santa Monica would later approve a revised housing plan, bringing the city into compliance, but not before development plans for 4,500 new residential units made it into the development pipeline. The largest city in the state, Los Angeles, avoided the Builder's Remedy by approving a revised Housing Element of the city's General Plan.

“Beverly Hills, Huntington Beach, Malibu, Palm Springs, Pasadena and West Hollywood are among the 124 jurisdictions in Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino and Imperial counties where the builder’s remedy could be in play because their latest housing plan hasn’t been approved,” report Dillon, citing confirmation from the state Department of Housing and Community Development as evidence. “Coronado, Del Mar and Solana Beach are among 11 cities in San Diego County in the same circumstances. Bay Area cities’ housing plans are due in January.”

Much of Dillon's analysis focuses on Santa Monica, a city with a complicated housing record, passing one of the nation's strongest rent control laws in the 1970s but subsequently allowing little room to grow, and holding basically steady in population as a result.

“In the decades since, regular disputes have erupted over proposals for large housing and commercial developments. Most recently, debates have centered on tearing down a downtown parking garage and replacing it with low-income housing, as well as building a 521-unit apartment building on what’s now a strip mall anchored by a grocery store,” writes Dillon. 

With the city only temporarily out of compliance with the RHNA process, Dillon reports that a slow growth organization known as Santa Monica Coalition for a Livable City “is urging the City Council to consider litigation to stop the projects.” Dillon notes that the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) is likely to present a sticking point for large projects proposed under the Builder's Remedy. “Additionally, because the builder’s remedy is untested in court, legal questions remain over what developments qualify,” writes Dillon.

Monday, October 24, 2022 in Los Angeles Times

An aerial view of Milwaukee’s Third Ward.

Plan to Potentially Remove Downtown Milwaukee’s Interstate Faces Public Scrutiny

The public is weighing in on a suite of options for repairing, replacing, or removing Interstate 794 in downtown Milwaukee.

August 27, 2023 - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Portland Bus Lane

‘Forward Together’ Bus System Redesign Rolling Out in Portland

Portland is redesigning its bus system to respond to the changing patterns of the post-pandemic world—with twin goals of increasing ridership and improving equity.

August 30, 2023 - Mass Transit

Conceptual rendering of Rikers Island redevelopment as renewable energy facility

Can New York City Go Green Without Renewable Rikers?

New York City’s bold proposal to close the jail on Rikers Island and replace it with green infrastructure is in jeopardy. Will this compromise the city’s ambitious climate goals?

August 24, 2023 - Mark McNulty

A rendering of the Utah City master planned, mixed-use development.

700-Acre Master-Planned Community Planned in Utah

A massive development plan is taking shape for lakefront property in Vineyard, Utah—on the site of a former U.S. Steel Geneva Works facility.

7 hours ago - Daily Herald

A line of cars wait at the drive-thru window of a starbucks.

More Cities Ponder the End of Drive-Thrus

Drive-thru fast food restaurants might be a staple of American life, but several U.S. cities are actively considering prohibiting the development of new drive-thrus for the benefit of traffic safety, air quality, and congestion.

August 31 - The Denver Post

Air pollution is visible in the air around high-rise buildings in Dhaka, Bangladesh.

Air Pollution World’s Worst Public Health Threat, Report Says

Air pollution is more likely to take years life off the lifespan of the average human than any other external factor, according to a recent report out of the University of Chicago.

August 31 -