The Paradox of Reduced Oil Reserve Estimates

Until recently, California's Monterey Shale was estimated to have the nation's highest amount of recoverable oil. Then the Energy Department revised their estimates, lowering it 96%, which turned out to be bad news for fracking moratorium advocates.

2 minute read

August 21, 2014, 11:00 AM PDT

By Irvin Dawid


Fracking opponents may have been greatly relieved by the downward revision of the Monterey Shale oil reserves by the Energy Information Administration (EIA) last May from 13.7 billion barrels to 600 million barrels, but from a moratorium perspective, it "may have helped the case for regulating instead of banning fracking," reports Governing staff writer Chris Kardish.

Opponents have long concerned with fracking's potential to contaminate and exhaust precious groundwater supplies during one of the state's worst recorded droughts and stimulate earthquakes as has been shown in Ohio. They were dissatisfied with the passage of the "Nation's Toughest Fracking Bill" (SB 4) last September, but were unsuccessful in passing moratorium legislation this year.

Making the case against the moratorium was Sen. Andy Vidak (R-Hanford) who represents parts of Kern County which "produces approximately 75% of California’s in-state oil and about 58% of the state’s total natural gas," according to the Greater Bakersfield Chamber of Commerce.

Vidak say the moratorium would’ve cost jobs --“thousands and thousands” of jobs. Vidak says the potential in Kern County and across the Monterey is huge, even with the lower estimate, because the same technological improvements that made fracking widespread will continue.

Making the case for the revision being good for regulation, bad for moratorium is Thad Kousser, a political science professor at the University of California, San Diego.

(T)he downgrade in estimated reserves has actually allayed some concerns about California becoming overrun with fracking operations, says Kousser. Californians are also happy to let the industry go about its business safely as long as they believe regulators have put the right guidelines in place, he says. “California is a state that, even though nationally we are looked at as environmental leaders, has always taken a ‘regulate but don’t ban’ position on the environment.”

No doubt that won't stop fracking opponents who have vowed [PDF] to try again with new moratorium legislation. However, Kardish writes that "Gov. Jerry Brown and some other state Democratic leaders support fracking." And Brown's Republican opponent in the November gubernatorial election, Neel Kashkari, is a major fracking booster.

Wednesday, August 20, 2014 in Governing

Portland Bus Lane

‘Forward Together’ Bus System Redesign Rolling Out in Portland

Portland is redesigning its bus system to respond to the changing patterns of the post-pandemic world—with twin goals of increasing ridership and improving equity.

August 30, 2023 - Mass Transit

An aerial view of Milwaukee’s Third Ward.

Plan to Potentially Remove Downtown Milwaukee’s Interstate Faces Public Scrutiny

The public is weighing in on a suite of options for repairing, replacing, or removing Interstate 794 in downtown Milwaukee.

August 27, 2023 - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

Conceptual rendering of Rikers Island redevelopment as renewable energy facility

Can New York City Go Green Without Renewable Rikers?

New York City’s bold proposal to close the jail on Rikers Island and replace it with green infrastructure is in jeopardy. Will this compromise the city’s ambitious climate goals?

August 24, 2023 - Mark McNulty

A rendering of the Utah City master planned, mixed-use development.

700-Acre Master-Planned Community Planned in Utah

A massive development plan is taking shape for lakefront property in Vineyard, Utah—on the site of a former U.S. Steel Geneva Works facility.

August 31 - Daily Herald

A line of cars wait at the drive-thru window of a starbucks.

More Cities Ponder the End of Drive-Thrus

Drive-thru fast food restaurants might be a staple of American life, but several U.S. cities are actively considering prohibiting the development of new drive-thrus for the benefit of traffic safety, air quality, and congestion.

August 31 - The Denver Post

Air pollution is visible in the air around high-rise buildings in Dhaka, Bangladesh.

Air Pollution World’s Worst Public Health Threat, Report Says

Air pollution is more likely to take years life off the lifespan of the average human than any other external factor, according to a recent report out of the University of Chicago.

August 31 - Phys.org